Should I hire a business development manager or use an agency?

The short answer

Hire when you have enough work to keep someone busy, a market you already understand, and the time to manage them. Use an agency when you want to test a market, need to start in weeks rather than months, or can't justify a full package yet. The real question isn't cost, it's who owns the relationships afterwards.

We're an agency, so take the comparison for what it is. We have also told plenty of people on a first call that hiring would serve them better, and the reasons are worth setting out properly.

What each one actually costs

A business development manager in construction isn't a cheap hire. Advertised roles in the South East currently sit around £55,000 to £62,000 base with on-target earnings of £75,000 to £80,000, plus a car allowance. Add employer's National Insurance, pension, a laptop and phone, CRM and data subscriptions, and the real annual cost of a good one lands well above the headline.

Then there's the part that doesn't appear on the spreadsheet. Recruitment takes two to three months. Notice periods take another one to three. Someone new needs six months before they are productive in a sector where buying cycles run in years. You are twelve months and a significant sum in before you know whether the hire was right.

An agency retainer is smaller, starts in weeks, and stops when you stop paying. That cuts both ways, and we'll come to it.

When hiring is the right call

  • You have steady work and need more of the same. A known market, a known buyer, an established reputation. That's a job someone can own.
  • The work needs someone on site and in person. If your sales happen over a cup of tea in a site cabin, that's a person, not a campaign.
  • You have the time to manage them. A BD hire with no direction fails, and it's nearly always the business that failed them, not the other way round.
  • You want the relationships permanently inside the business. This is the strongest argument for hiring and it's a good one.

When an agency makes more sense

  • You are testing a market or a sector. Finding out whether housing associations, or a new region, or a different package size is worth pursuing, before you commit a salary to it.
  • You need to start now. Weeks rather than a hiring process.
  • You can't justify a full package. Plenty of good firms are at the stage where a hire is a stretch and doing nothing is worse.
  • The director is the brand. In a lot of construction businesses the person people want to deal with is the owner. An agency can run that person's outreach without taking their week. A new employee can't be them.

The question that matters more than cost

Who owns the relationships when it ends?

With a hire, the relationships sit with a person who can leave and take them. With an agency, it depends entirely on how the agency works. If the outreach goes out from a company page or an agency inbox, the relationships are theirs. If it goes out from your own profile, in your name, the connections stay on your profile whatever happens to the arrangement.

That's a fair question to ask any agency before you sign, ours included.

The option nobody sells you

Both at once, in sequence. Use an agency to find out where the work actually is, and hire once you know what you are hiring for. A brief that says "find us more work" produces a bad hire. A brief that says "we win packages with regional contractors in the East of England, here are forty relationships already warm, keep them going and build more" produces a good one.

When neither is worth doing

If you have no capacity to take on new work, or nobody who can respond to an enquiry within a couple of days, neither option will help you. We would rather say that on a first call than take a retainer for six months and watch it go nowhere.

Side by side

In-house hireAgency
Monthly costSalary, NI, pension, tools, deskA retainer, typically four figures
Time to runningTwo to four months, including notice and ramp-upUsually two to three weeks
Who manages themYouThem
Sector knowledgeWhatever they arrive withShould already be there, worth checking
What happens when you get busyThey keep going, if you keep managing themIt keeps going regardless
If it doesn't work outA difficult conversation and a gapNotice period
Knowledge retentionStays with you, until they leaveSits with the agency
CapacityOne person's full attentionShared, but with a team behind it

What it actually costs to do nothing

This is the comparison most firms skip. A pipeline that depends on referrals is fine until a client consolidates, a contact moves, or a sector slows. The cost of neither option is usually the biggest number on this page, and the hardest to see until it arrives.

Whichever way you go, it's worth knowing what consistent outreach actually produces. Our LinkedIn outreach benchmarks set out acceptance and reply rates across our UK construction client companies, which is a reasonable yardstick for what to expect from a first year of either arrangement.

Related questions

The questions that come with it

How much does a business development manager cost in construction?

Advertised base salaries for experienced BD managers commonly sit in the £50,000 to £65,000 range, with on-target earnings higher again, plus car allowance, National Insurance and pension. The loaded annual cost is well above the advertised salary.

How long before a new BD hire produces work?

Expect three months of recruitment and notice, then around six months before they are productive, because construction buying cycles are long. Twelve months is a fair point to judge the decision.

Is an agency cheaper than hiring?

In monthly cost, usually yes, and it starts far sooner and stops when you stop. Whether it's better value depends on whether you need relationships owned inside the business permanently.

Who owns the relationships if I use an agency?

Ask before you sign. If outreach goes out from your own profile in your name, the connections stay with you. If it goes out from an agency account or a company page, they do not.

Can I do both?

That's often the sensible route. Use outreach to find out where the work is, then hire against what you have learned rather than against a vague brief.

Not sure which one you need?

Worth a conversation. If the answer is that you should hire, we'll say so, and we'll tell you what to brief them on.