Our last lead generation agency got us nothing. What do we do differently?

The short answer

Usually one of four things went wrong: the target list was too broad, the messages were generic, nobody followed up the replies on your side, or the campaign was stopped before construction's buying cycle could play out. Work out which before you hire anyone else, because the wrong diagnosis means paying twice for the same outcome.

This is one of the most common things we hear on a first call, and it's not always the agency's fault. It often is. But not always, and it matters which, because you can't fix the wrong problem.

Cause one: the list was too broad

If the brief was "construction companies in the South East", the campaign was always going to struggle. A list that wide means messages that could have gone to anyone, which means messages that read like they went to everyone.

The better version is uncomfortably narrow. Thirty to fifty named organisations you actually want to work with, chosen deliberately, approved by you before anything is sent.

Ask yourself: could you name the companies that were contacted on your behalf? If not, that's the problem.

Cause two: volume replaced relevance

Plenty of agencies win on promised volume because it sounds like value. Five hundred messages a month is easy to sell and easy to deliver, and it's almost always worse than fifty messages that reference real work.

The tell is in the copy. If the message that went out in your name could have been sent by any of your competitors with the logo swapped, it was never going to start a conversation.

Ask yourself: have you read the actual messages that went out under your name? Many people have not.

Cause three: nobody followed up on your side

This is the uncomfortable one, and it's more common than people expect. Replies came in, landed in an inbox, and sat there while the person who was supposed to chase them was busy running jobs.

We have had campaigns producing good conversations where the client could not tell us whether any of them turned into work, simply because nobody had the hours to find out. The outreach was working. The handover was not.

Ask yourself: who owned the replies, and did they actually have time?

Cause four: it was stopped too early

Construction buying cycles don't care about your three month trial. A relationship started in March can turn into an enquiry in December, when a scheme finally gets funded. Campaigns judged at week eight are usually judged before the thing they were built to produce could possibly have happened.

That's not a reason to tolerate nothing happening. It's a reason to agree upfront what month one, month three and month six should each look like, so you are measuring the right thing at the right time.

Six questions to ask before you sign with anyone else

  1. Who writes the messages, a person or a tool?
  2. Can I see and approve the target list before anything goes out?
  3. How many messages a day, and what happens if that volume risks my account?
  4. Can I read every message before it's sent?
  5. What happens when someone replies, who handles it, and who owns the handover to me?
  6. What should month one look like, as opposed to month six?

Any agency that can't answer all six plainly is one to walk away from.

Three red flags

  • Guaranteed meetings. Nobody can guarantee that another human being will take a call. A guarantee usually means low-quality meetings booked to hit a number.
  • Volume as the headline. If the pitch leads with how many people they will contact, you are buying reach, not relationships.
  • No named list. If they won't tell you who they are contacting, you have no control over how your name is used.

Where we would tell you not to bother

If you have no capacity to take on new work, or nobody who can respond to a reply within a couple of days, outreach won't help you. Fix that first. We would rather say so on a first call than take a retainer for six months and watch it go nowhere.

Related questions

The questions that come with it

Why did my lead generation agency not deliver any meetings?

Usually the target list was too broad, the messaging was generic, replies were not followed up internally, or the campaign was stopped before construction's buying cycle could play out.

How long should I give a lead generation campaign before judging it?

Agree milestones upfront. Expect early signals such as connection acceptance and conversations within weeks, but real pipeline in months, because construction buying cycles are long.

What should I ask a lead generation agency before signing?

Who writes the messages, whether you can approve the target list and the copy before anything is sent, how many messages go out daily, who handles replies, and what each month should look like.

Are guaranteed meetings realistic in B2B lead generation?

No. Nobody can guarantee another person will take a call, and guarantees tend to produce meetings booked to hit a number rather than meetings worth having.

Whose fault is it if the leads don't convert?

Sometimes the agency's, sometimes not. If replies sat unanswered, the outreach was working and the handover was not.

The six questions, asked of us

We'll answer all six on a first call, in writing if you want them in writing, before you decide anything.